In putting together these rankings, heavy emphasis was put on recent success (specifically, the 2005 & 2006 seasons), the current season, the future which lies ahead, the league in which they pitch, and one's health resume. Essentially, my basis came down to which 25 pitchers you would trust most with the ball in their hands...going forward (in 2007 and beyond, to a much lesser degree).
(Disclaimer: These are not fantasy rankings)
(It should be noted that these rankings were not made on a whim, as I studied and analyzed every meaningful stat out there -- PECOTA peripherals, defined ERA+ numbers, replacement value, PERA stats, EqERA stats, etc.)
1. Johan Santana: 6-5, 3.30 ERA, 91 K's
2. Jake Peavy: 7-1, 1.68 ERA, 92 K's
3. Roy Oswalt: 6-4, 3.20 ERA, 57 K's
4. Brandon Webb: 5-3, 3.39 ERA, 75 K's
5. Roy Halladay: 5-2, 3.90 ERA, 45 K's
6. John Lackey: 9-3, 2.37 ERA, 65 K's
7. John Smoltz: 7-2, 2.82 ERA, 65 K's
8. C.C. Sabathia: 8-1, 3.78 ERA, 75 K's
9. Josh Beckett: 8-0, 2.95 ERA, 59 K's
10. Chien-Ming Wang: 4-4, 4.19 ERA, 25 K's
11. Dan Haren: 6-2, 1.70 ERA, 70 K's
12. Carlos Zambrano: 5-5, 5.62 ERA, 51 K's
13. Erik Bedard: 4-3, 3.73 ERA, 95 K's
14. Cole Hamels: 8-2, 3.55 ERA, 91 K's
15. Ben Sheets: 6-3, 3.51 ERA, 48 K's
16. Justin Verlander: 5-2, 3.44 ERA, 50 K's
17. Felix Hernandez: 3-3, 4.10 ERA, 42 K's
18. Jeremy Bonderman: 5-0, 3.27 ERA, 60 K's
19. Rich Hill: 4-4, 2.89 ERA, 63 K's
20. Tim Lincecum: 2-0, 4.05 ERA, 39 K's
21. Andy Pettitte: 3-4, 2.96 ERA, 41 K's
22. Chris Carpenter: 0-1, 7.50 ERA, 3 K's
23. Scott Kazmir: 3-3, 3.95 ERA, 71 K's
24. Barry Zito: 6-5, 3.87 ERA, 44 K's
25. Matt Cain: 2-5, 3.42 ERA, 54 K's
Others which garnered consideration (in no particular order): Harang, Schilling, Clemens, Jered Weaver, Chris Young, Hudson, Willis, Harden (way too injury prone...and likely bullpen-bound)
...I tried being COMPLETELY objective (if you know me, you know it pained me to drop Wang all the way down to #10). Where do we agree/disagree???
(As I'm writing this, the Red Sox just tied the game...in the 9th, on a Wily Mo Pena single. Francona is managing this team perfectly this year, thus far. It makes me sick.) Goodnight!